powered by Google  
CBSSports.com League admits Billups' 3-pointer should not have counted - NBA Sports News   Track your favorite teams and players.
Free membership, Register Now
Already a member, Log In
 


Community | Help
Home    Fantasy    NFL  |  MLB  |  NBA  |  NHL  |  College FB  |  College BK  |  Golf  |  Racing  |  Tennis  |  Horses  |  MMA  |  More
CBS College  |  High School  |  Mobile  |  Shop
NBA Home | Scoreboard | Standings | Schedules | Stats | Teams | Players | Transactions | Injuries | Video | Fantasy News
 

League admits Billups' 3-pointer should not have counted

 

NEW YORK -- The NBA admitted Chauncey Billups' 3-pointer at the end of the third quarter of Monday's Detroit-Orlando playoff game should not have counted, but said referees weren't allowed to review instant replay to determine that.

Advertisement  
 

League president Joel Litvin also said the disputed shot, which gave Detroit a 78-76 lead in its 100-93 victory, could not have been replayed after the clock malfunction was discovered.

"After reviewing the video of last night's Pistons-Magic game, we determined that the play that concluded with Chauncey Billups' 3-point field goal at the end of the third quarter took approximately 5.7 seconds," Litvin said in a statement. "Because there were only 5.1 seconds remaining in the quarter when the play began, the shot would not have counted had the clock continued to run."

Billups was bringing the ball up the court for the Pistons when the clock froze at 4.8 seconds because of a problem with the arena's timing system. After he made the shot, the game referees had to estimate how long the play took without the aid of replay because the league's rules don't allow for reviewing a play to determine when the clock started.

The league said the timekeeper who worked the game was from a "neutral" city, standard procedure for all games.

After the game, Orlando coach Stan Van Gundy said the referees indicated it took 4.6 seconds to complete the play. Lead official Steve Javie declined a postgame interview by a pool reporter.

"The referees followed proper procedure in addressing the clock malfunction by estimating the elapsed time and using their judgment as to whether the shot was taken in time," Litvin said. "Under NBA rules, the referees did not have the option of using instant replay and a timing device to determine exactly how much time had elapsed, nor do the rules allow for a re-play after a clock malfunction is discovered."

The NBA frequently talks about expanding the instant-replay capabilities for game officials, but this might finally get the league to act.

"The NBA Competition Committee was scheduled to discuss the possible expanded use of instant replay at its meeting at the end of the month and we will raise, for the Committee's consideration, the use of replay in situations like this," Litvin said.

AP NEWS
The Associated Press News Service

Copyright 2007-2008, The Associated Press, All Rights Reserved
 
Talk Back
Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Aug 18, 2006

May 6, 2008 11:58 pm
Listen, instant replay doesn't work wonders in ANY sport... and it won't work here.   Yeah, THIS CALL would have been corrected, but what about other things?  The game  would last  5 hours if they could review everything that matters in a game.

Look at the nfl, the best example.  They have replay , but with 100 flaws.  Each team gets 2 and
...(more)
Reputation:96
Level:Superstar
Since:Nov 1, 2006

May 7, 2008 10:01 am

just read this and found it quite interesting, it was something I did not know and assume most of us out there didn't know either.

According to NBA spokesman Tim Frank, the clock is stopped when the official blows in his whistle, period. The operator has nothing to do with it.

The operator can stop the clock on his own of course, but he is considered the back-up to th ...(more)

Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Feb 22, 2008

May 7, 2008 9:56 am

As a league that is tarnished with bad calls, favorable calls, "jordan rules", conspiracy theories (did you read the ROY blog) etc., they had no choice but to come out and admit this.  Sad thing is people know it happens. 

Don't worry Magic fans.  They wil ljust adjust how they call game 2 and you w ...(more)

Reputation:99
Level:Superstar
Since:Aug 16, 2006

May 7, 2008 11:34 am
I hear people defending it whether it be Pistons fans or analysts.  "Magic had the lead and lost it" blah blah blah...  well they had a 4 point lead (which should have been 7) and lost by 10... well when they were down by 3 they were shooting 3's... which all an ...(more)
Reputation:98
Level:Superstar
Since:Jul 8, 2007

May 6, 2008 9:02 pm
this happens all the time, leagues admit mistakes, but obviously dont care enough to avoid problems like this.

its common sense and the responsibility of leagues to give refs the ability to right wrongs or use all the tools at their disposal to get things right...

all this technology just sitting there to solve the problem and they choose to just give the home team t
...(more)
Reputation:91
Level:All-Star
Since:Nov 1, 2007

May 6, 2008 10:37 pm
THE REAL POINT THAT IS PISSING OFF Magic FANS IS.We arent saying we still would have won.We are saying that shot gave detroit mad momentum because that was a "buzzer beater"in their home court.Which believ it or not changed momentum even though the magic had a 4 point lead in the 4th.And number 2 magic fans are mad at why only 0. ...(more)
Reputation:90
Level:All-Star
Since:May 6, 2007

May 6, 2008 7:47 pm

From what I see you had 3 options once the clock malfunction occured and the NBA used the worst one.

1) Have the referees guess the elapsed seconds.  I mean...seriously..how is it even possible to do this.  I bet even if a referee had been counting to himself, he still wouldve been a second off, and they were asked to do it by just trying to recollect how long the play took ...(more)

Reputation:93
Level:All-Star
Since:Jan 28, 2008

May 7, 2008 9:58 am
(POLL) (Poll)  I think the should make a rule that the refs can look at a instant replay so then ther would be alot less confussion.
Reputation:96
Level:Superstar
Since:Mar 5, 2008

May 7, 2008 12:12 am
it's hard enough in this day and age to play the game, as the officiating is horribly erratic from crew to crew, and sometimes from quarter to quarter within a crew.  I will grant that it is an incredibly difficult and largely thankless job to be an official in this or any other sport. 

It certainly doesn't help any when the refs are handicapped in situations like
...(more)
Reputation:98
Level:Superstar
Since:Aug 12, 2006

May 6, 2008 9:10 pm
Orlando had a 4 point lead some time AFTER that mistake...they couldn't hold,so they lost.The End.
Reputation:79
Level:Pro
Since:Nov 13, 2007

May 6, 2008 8:28 pm

Thats some great home Court Advantage.  It is sad when things other than players i.e. refs and clocks alter how games are played.  I am not going for either team in this series but to me the fact of confidence and getting on a roll can affect the outcome of the game.  The Magic still could have won but it is hard whe ...(more)

Reputation:98
Level:Superstar
Since:Mar 7, 2008

May 7, 2008 11:56 am

 Let's get this straight.........take the 3 points away and the Magic still lose!!

Does'nt matter anyway because the Magic will be swept in this series and this will all be forgotten!

Pistons NATION!!! ...(more)

Reputation:75
Level:Pro
Since:Mar 5, 2008

May 6, 2008 8:35 pm
Last year it was Robert Horry on Steve Nash, now it's this. LIke I know this call isn't as bad, but how do we know this isn't ganna stop. Like what if the Pistons win in 6, that should influence the NBA to ...(more)
Reputation:93
Level:All-Star
Since:Aug 17, 2006

May 6, 2008 9:00 pm