Overrated-underrated isn't a study in talent. It's a study of how what we perceive differs from what's actually happening on the diamond. 

With that said it's got to be J D Drew.

at least for active players.

Overrated-underrated isn't a study in talent. It's a study of how what we perceive differs from what's actually happening on the diamond.

So it's got to be JD Drew and Bobby Abreu for active players.

Alex Rodriguez......hands down.  Most of you are prisoners of the media, so I expect you to be perplexed by this choice....but its an easy one.  This guy is supposed to be the best player in the game, yet he can't win.  He is an annual, perennial choke artist.  He feasts on mediocre pitching during the year and puts up MVP numbers, but he hits like a pitcher when it matters most.  For all of you folks continuing to think Jeter is the most overrated, you're kidding yourself.  When you have 4 rings, there is no such thing as overrated.  On top of that, Jeter is able to do what he does performance-enhancement free......the same cannot be said about A-Rod, the perennial choke artist.