First of all take out the steroid guys from the conversation because they would be in the HOF if they didn't get caught cheating. And if they didn't cheat they never would've done that in the first place
You listed two players who accomplished the feat, one is Jeff Bagwell. He should get into the HOF but is not eligible yet. The other was Albert Belle ...
Besides his incredible off the field issues, he only played 10 full seasons and played his last season at 33 years old due to injury. He was well onto the HOF before retiring and had he not been such a jerk he probably would be there already. He was a HOF caliber player
But if Fielder put up the numbers Belle did over the next 10 seasons he would be at 453 HRs and 1409 RBIs at the age of 33. Players rarely retire at that young of an age barring career ending injuries so it would be highly unlikely that he doesn't hit an additional 47 home runs or an additional 191 RBIs over the course of the rest of his career. Doing so would put him at 500 home runs and 1600 RBIs. There is no non-steroid user in the history of the MLB who is eligible for the Hall of Fame that has 500 home runs and isn't in the HOF, also all 23 retired players who have at least 1600 RBIs are in the HOF
Obviously I am not saying Prince is a sure fire HOFer by any means. There are unforeseeables such as sudden retirement, careeer ending injuries, or career plaguing injuries that would keep his overall career numbers below that of the HOF level
|
