whos better

Wh do you think will be more valuable to their team in the NBA? Derrik Rose or CDR?

 i think rose, because look at the 16 teams in the NBA playoofs.. almost everyone of those teams has a good point and rose is just that

what are your opinions guys/gals

In my opinion Derrick Rose can be as big of a player as he wonts to be.  It all depends on him....When he gets drafted and gets to a team he has two options 1. be satisfied with making it and just take the money and run (see Vince Carter) or 2. get hungry and motivated to become apart of something (see Kobe Bryant).  He will still be the star of the team but thats his paths.  With CDR I see him as more of a Tayshaun Prince.  A great player and a starter who can change the game but not the best player/ nor the player in the limelight on whatever team that takes him.

Personally though as a memphian I had more time to watch CDR and will probably follow his career with more interest then Roses' career

Chances are CDR will go to a better team and be a second or third option.  Because of that, he'll probably have more team success early.  But Rose is a franchise type player and as a team has time to build around him, I think he'll end up being a superstar in the league.