Pick AL East All Star Team

Dude, is that a Dolphins shirt! Yikes, you are a glutton for punishment!!

As for the AL East all star team, they're called the Boston Red Sox.

NufCed.

I think it would be:

C- Posada (a couple years ago it would be Varitek, but Posada just had a career year at 38)

1B- Carlos Pena (Comeback player of the year last year)

2B- Robinson Cano (If he is not already, he will be a superstar in a few years)

SS- Derek Jeter (By default; other than him the only other "good" SS in the AL East is Lugo, i guess?)

3B- AROD (do we really have a choice here?)

OF- Manny Ramierez (bad year last year, but will have a better one this year), Vernon Wells (Best offensive player on the Blue Jays) Carl Crawford (Speed and defense)

SP- Josh Becket (snubbed for Cy), Roy Halladay (Great every year), Scott Kazmir (has some nasty stuff), Bartolo Calon (Just Kidding! ;-)!) 

RP- Jonothan Papelbon (too good, and he has a slider now), Joba Chamberlain (100 mph every pitch), BJ Ryan (If he can get back to form) Note: If Manny Delcarmen has a good year this year he could be on here. Also I did not put Mariano Rivera on here perposfully. He is still effective, just not All-star anymore.

C- Jorge Posada (gettin old, but still a force at the plate, although i hate him)

1B- Carlos Pena (he got pop!)

2B- Robinson Cano (pretty swing) with Dustin Pedroia closing in

3B- A-rod (best in the bigs)

SS- Derek Jeter (one of the Yankees i respect)

OF- Manny Ramirez

OF- Carl Crawford

OF- Alex Rios

SP- Beckett, Wang, Halladay, Kazmir, and Phil Hughes (in a few years by default)

Markakis over Alex Rios?!?!  You have forsaken me Matthew!

C - Jorge Posada (Jason Varitek is the only other one to get consideration, but he can't touch "Dumbo" offensively)

1B - Carlos Pena

2B - Brian Roberts (how is everyone overlooking him?)

SS - Derek Jeter (not many other choices... are there any?)

3B - Alex Rodriguez

LF - Manny Ramirez

CF - Vernon Wells

RF - Nick Markakis/Alex Rios (Rios has more speed, Markakis slightly more pop, pretty even here)

DH - David Ortiz

SP 1 - Josh Beckett

SP 2 - Roy Halladay

SP 3 - Chien Ming Wang

SP 4 - Scott Kazmir

SP 5 - James Shields (gets the nod over Daisuke Matsuzaka, because if you put him on the Red Sox or Yankees he'd be a star)

RP - Jonathan Papelbon

RP - Mariano Rivera

RP - B.J. Ryan (when healthy)