powered by Google  
  Track your favorite teams and players.
Free membership, Register Now
Already a member, Log In
 


Community | Help
Trying to make sense -- again -- of NASCAR's justice system - Auto Racing Sports News
  Home   Fantasy     NFL  |  MLB  |  NBA  |  NHL  |  College FB  |  College BK  |  Golf  |  Racing  |  Tennis  |  Cycling  |  MMA  |  More CBS College | High School | Mobile | Shop  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 Horses Home
 Live Racing
 Youbet Update
 Carryovers
 Free Selections
 Contests
 U. of BET
 Message Board
 
 
 
 
 
 
 Cycling Home
 Results
 Standings
 Stages
 Teams
 Riders
 Message Board
 
 
 
 
 
 
 Arena Football
 Boxing
 CBS College Sports
 CBS Sports TV
 College Baseball
 College Hockey
 Horse Racing
 Collegiate Nationals
 Message Board
 Poker
 Soccer
 SPiN
 Tour de France
 Video
 WNBA
 Women's Coll BK
 World Sports
 
 Site Index
 
 
 CBS College Sports
 Coll Sports Tonight
 Get CBS Coll Sports
 XXL - Watch Now
 Talent Bios
 Schedules
 School Sites
 
 
 Find your School
 '08 Football Preview
 Football Rankings
 Football Stats
 Hoops Recruiting
 Hoops Rankings
 Hoops Stats
 Video Highlights
 
 
 Featured Application
 Mobile Web
 Alerts
 Applications
 Video
 
 
 Home
 NFL
 NCAA
 MLB
 NBA
 NHL
 Fantasy
 
Auto Racing Home | Series: Sprint Cup | Nationwide | Trucks | IndyCar | Formula 1 | NHRA | ALMS | Grand Am ||| Teams | Tracks | Video
 

Trying to make sense -- again -- of NASCAR's justice system

 

NASCAR has made billions of dollars over the years licensing nearly any kind of merchandise and souvenir possible.

After the turn of events this week, the new NASCAR "Can of Worms" is the latest product to hit the market.

Carl Edwards has points taken away and yet he's still the Vegas winner. (Getty Images)  
Carl Edwards has points taken away and yet he's still the Vegas winner. (Getty Images)  
The penalties and fines that were both given and rescinded this week have opened a veritable Pandora's box of problems for the sanctioning body.

First came the ruling on Carl Edwards' oil reservoir lid, which was originally reported as being missing but later simply loose, with one of its bolts gone.

The winner in Las Vegas was slapped with a 100-point penalty as well as losing the 10-point bonus for the victory that would have been used to seed the Chase should Edwards make the postseason.

So on the one hand, NASCAR is saying the car was illegal and Roush Fenway racing is guilty of cheating. One hundred points were taken away as well as the 10 bonus points.

Yet Edwards is still considered the winner of the UAW-Dodge 400.

Which is it?

If the 10 points are erased, how can Edwards still be considered the winner in a car that was clearly outside the rulebook?

Team owner Jack Roush and the organization's president, Geoff Smith, steadfastly claimed the missing bolt was not intentional and simply a failure that took place over the course of a 400-mile race.

Perhaps they're right.

Now I'll admit that I can't change the oil on my family car, so I spoke to some other mechanics and crewmembers that are well-versed in the intricate details of a NASCAR engine.

Basically, all told me any type of air that is allowed to be sucked into an open vent such as an oil reservoir would provide additional down force, a coveted aerodynamic edge, especially with the new Sprint Cup car.

CONTINUED: 1 · 2 · Next »
 
Talk Back
Reputation:99
Level:Superstar
Since:Sep 26, 2006

March 7, 2008 1:33 pm

The writer forgot to mention, or my A.D.D. didn't allow me to remember if he did, that Carl Edwards and Osbourne committed ANOTHER rule violation when their tire got away.  This happened earlier in the race and NASCAR sent Carl to the back.  Well it happened again towards the end of the race, and they did NOT invoke a penalty.  They said "a cameraman, who was not with Fo ...(more)

Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Feb 4, 2007

March 6, 2008 10:43 pm

I don't know if Edwards and his team are or aren't guilty....by guilty, I mean intentionally knowing about the loose bolt.  I don't care.  The fact is, NASCAR has to stick to their guns about altering the COT, in any way.  That is why I think Edwards should be penalized.  That is why I don't think Robby Gordon's penalty should have been reduced.  Fur ...(more)

Reputation:96
Level:Superstar
Since:Sep 26, 2007

March 6, 2008 11:55 pm
Edwards cheated was caught and has to pay. He should lose the belt and give it to Dale period. Nascar if you dont do this you are friggin out of your minds and lieing to everyone. Hell you cost Dale alot last year when he was caught but let Edwards off where is justice. Give the title and win to Dale.
Reputation:92
Level:All-Star
Since:Nov 25, 2007

March 7, 2008 3:11 pm
It's hillbilly justice.  thats it.  you watch the Dukes of Hazzard don't you?  well, your not supposed to ask questions.  just jump into your street rod and kick some yankee #@~.  Don't ask any #*/  $0~* questions.!
Reputation:92
Level:All-Star
Since:Oct 15, 2007

March 7, 2008 12:53 am
We've all seen the amount of vibration in the cars during a race, right ?? What happens if a bolt is not tightened to the point where it will not vibrate itself loose and maybe off. Not trying to make excuses for anybody , but it could happen right ?? I know it has happened to me with lug nuts, so if Edwards did not have that bolt in place at the end of a race, how was it missed before the race by ...(more)
Reputation:96
Level:Superstar
Since:Jan 26, 2008

March 6, 2008 6:54 pm
so you have 400 mile races and Nascar expects the car to be in the same shape it was at the start of the race? what if the car is damaged in a wreck and a bolt or nut comes off... is that car illegal and that driver's points taken away?
Reputation:25
Level:Rookie
Since:Mar 4, 2007

March 8, 2008 3:00 am

N -- Nervous

A -- Anal

S -- Suits

C -- Can't

A -- Administer

R -- Racing

 

Lets face it if there is anything that could kill the sport it's NASCAR.....  All these teams and sponsor's should pull the NASCAR logo off their cars in protest until they pull their heads out and follow the RULES they write.

 
 
 
 
Pete Pistone
Recent Columns